Cincinnati Doesn’t Need to Be Silicon Valley: Insights from Midwest Investing

At Cintrifuse Capital, we invest with a strong conviction that Cincinnati and the broader Midwest represent one of venture capital’s most overlooked opportunities. Through investing and working alongside founders across the region, we’ve seen firsthand the distinct advantages that position this ecosystem to produce high-growth, venture-scale companies.

Our experience has reinforced a clear reality: Cincinnati is not Silicon Valley, and it doesn’t need to be. The region’s strengths, from capital efficiency to customer proximity to a plethora of talented operators, are exactly what enable startups to become durable businesses that generate strong investment outcomes.

Based on what we’ve seen in the market, here are five lessons that continue to strengthen our confidence in Cincinnati’s long-term potential:

‍

1. The best founders don’t always look like “startup founders”

A lot of the founders Cintrifuse Capital has backed in Cincinnati don’t fit the Silicon Valley archetype. They’re often more operationally focused and less flashy; less interested in telling the story and more obsessed with building the business.

That can lead to great founders being overlooked early, especially if investors are pattern-matching based on a particular type of polish. But over time, execution wins. A founder who is relentlessly focused on customers and outcomes tends to build something durable.

‍

2. The talent is deeper than outsiders realize

The Midwest, and Ohio in particular, is still underestimated as a talent market. Which is one of the biggest blind spots we see from outside investors. The reality is there’s a meaningful concentration of people here who know how to build and operate.

Cincinnati has institutions like the University of Cincinnati producing incredible engineers, Miami University churning out an impressive number of big-thinking visionaries, tech scale-ups like Astronomer and VNDLY that have helped create a generation of hypergrowth operators, and leaders coming out of P&G, Kroger, as well as major insurance companies, who deeply understand storytelling, operations, and how to sell.

‍

3. Customer access is a real unfair advantage

One of the most underrated strengths of this region is access to real buyers. Cincinnati founders can often get meetings, pilots, and feedback loops faster than people in many cities because it’s a tight-knit community with a real “rising tide lifts all boats” mentality.

Most founders and operators are only one or two degrees removed from a decision-maker at a major enterprise. Even when startups are too early for enterprise procurement, they can still get valuable feedback quickly. That enables them to build smarter and waste far less time chasing the theoretical.

‍

4. Capital efficiency isn’t a slogan here. It’s embedded in the culture.

Capital efficiency isn’t something founders here “talk about.” It’s inherent in their DNA. Teams stay lean (sometimes too lean), and there’s a strong bias toward real revenue and real fundamentals, not vanity metrics.

Midwest founders tend to treat fundraising as a tool, not the goal, and they treat every dollar like it matters. Sometimes that can mean companies grow less parabolically than their Silicon Valley peers.  However, building real traction with less burn is always a competitive advantage, and we have seen it become even more valuable in recent, tighter capital markets.

‍

5. Liquidity and exits happen more often than people think

One of the most common misconceptions that we hear is that the best outcomes mostly happen elsewhere. But Cincinnati has a meaningful track record of companies getting acquired or building profitable growth businesses.

Not everything needs to be a unicorn to be a great investment. Would we love a few more unicorns to come out of Cincinnati? Of course. But companies that raise a reasonable amount of angel and/or venture capital at fair valuations can deliver huge returns to investors with an eight-figure exit.

And we have recent examples that prove this point, including Medality and Genetesis. These outcomes may not always make national headlines, but they create real liquidity. They also recycle talent and capital back into the ecosystem, which is how regions like this compound over time.

‍

Cincinnati (and the broader Midwest) is not Silicon Valley, but it also doesn’t need to be to produce great outcomes. We have our own distinct ingredients and advantages that enable startups to thrive here.

Now we just need more investors to recognize that what they’re used to seeing on the coasts may not exist here, and that’s not a problem. That’s the point.

‍

Cintrifuse is a non-profit organization accelerating startup growth in Greater Cincinnati by leveraging its three branches: Cintrifuse, Cintrifuse Capital, and StartupCincy. Together, these branches create an ecosystem which aims to amplify Cincinnati’s reputation as one of the best places in the Midwest to launch and scale a business.